Can I use this GE part in my whirlpool refrig?
Answer Hello Mike. No, Based on the model number 4387489 is the correct defrost thermostat.
Not defrosting. How can I tell which to replace?
Answer Hello Andrew. You will need to test the defrost heater and the defrost thermostat. They should read closed for continuity when cold. You can test this with a multi-meter TJMA-DMT3. I will include a link at the end to assist you how to use the multi-meter if needed. If both parts are good, you will need to replace the defrost timer. Once the problem is repaired, you will need to thaw out the ice on the coils before the unit will operate properly. http://forum.appliancepartspros.com/oven-repair-including-ranges-cooktops/4810-how-check-continuity-ohmmeter.html