The most common oven problems around Thanksgiving & how to keep dinner on track

The kitchen becomes the heart of the home during Thanksgiving, and the oven takes center stage. But with all the holiday cooking, ovens are often pushed to their limits. Problems can be a real headache, but many have simple solutions you can tackle on your own. Here’s how to troubleshoot the most common oven issues and keep your Thanksgiving dinner on track.

1. Uneven heating

One of the most common issues home cooks encounter is uneven heating. This problem can show up in several ways, like food cooking faster on one side or certain dishes taking longer than expected. If you’ve noticed that your food comes out perfectly on one side and undercooked on the other, uneven heating might be the culprit.

Common causes

Uneven heating can result from a few different issues:

• Misplaced oven racks can block airflow, leading to hot or cold spots.
• Heating elements may have wear or damage, particularly if your oven is older.
• Blocked air vents can restrict the circulation needed for even cooking.

DIY fixes

If you’re experiencing uneven heating, try these quick fixes to keep your dishes on track:

• Check and adjust rack placement to promote better airflow, especially for larger items like a turkey.
• Inspect the heating elements for visible wear, such as discoloration or breakage, and clean any residue buildup.
• Rotate your food halfway through cooking to help distribute heat evenly across the dish.

2. Inaccurate temperature

Have you ever set your oven to a certain temperature, only to find that food takes longer to cook, or worse, comes out burnt? Inconsistent oven temperatures are another common issue that can throw off your cooking times and impact the overall quality of your meal.

Common causes

Several factors can contribute to an oven not reaching or maintaining the desired temperature:

• A faulty thermostat can misread or misadjust the temperature.
• A broken temperature sensor might fail to send accurate information to the control board.

DIY fixes

To address temperature issues, try the following steps:

• Use an oven thermometer to test the accuracy of your oven’s temperature. Place it in the center and compare its reading to the set temperature.
• Calibrate the oven according to the manufacturer’s instructions if you find a noticeable discrepancy.
• Replace the temperature sensor if it’s damaged or malfunctioning, which is often a straightforward fix.

3. Broken or worn door seals

A worn or broken door seal may seem like a minor issue, but it can significantly impact how well your oven holds heat. If heat leaks through gaps in the seal, it leads to temperature fluctuations, which can throw off cooking times and lead to undercooked or unevenly cooked food.

Common causes

Most often a door gasket can wear out with frequent use.

DIY fixes

Luckily, fixing a broken seal is generally quick and easy. Here’s what you can do:

• Inspect the door gasket for any visible cracks, warping, or gaps.
• Replace the gasket if it’s worn, cracked, or loose. You can find replacement gaskets at www.appliancepartspros.com.

Read more: What to do when your range or oven stops working in the middle of holiday baking

4. Faulty igniters (for gas ovens)

If you’re using a gas oven, a faulty igniter could be a potential problem. When the igniter isn’t working correctly, the oven may struggle to heat up or fail to ignite entirely. This is especially frustrating if you’re relying on your oven for multiple dishes.

Common causes

Gas oven igniters wear down over time, especially with frequent use worn-out igniters often lead to slow or failed heating.

DIY fixes

Here are some ways to check and potentially fix a faulty igniter:

• Listen for a clicking sound, this is a good sign the igniter is trying to work. If you don’t hear it, the igniter might need replacement.
• Remove and replace the igniter if you’ve confirmed it’s faulty. Replacement igniters are generally available at hardware or appliance stores, and installing them is straightforward with basic tools.

5. Electrical issues in electric ovens

Electric ovens come with their own unique issues. Electrical problems can be especially challenging, as they may cause the oven to shut off or not turn on at all. Whether you’re prepping sides or baking rolls, an unexpected power loss can quickly throw a wrench in your plans.

Common causes

Electrical issues in ovens are often tied to:

• Blown fuses or tripped circuit breakers, which cut power to the oven.
• Faulty internal wiring that may cause intermittent power loss.

DIY fixes

You can often address electrical issues with these steps:

• Check your circuit breakers to see if they’ve tripped. If so, reset them.
• Inspect fuses and replace them if you find any damage.

Read more: Thanksgiving appliance checklist: What to check and fix before the holiday

6. Preheating problems

A slow-to-preheat oven can be inconvenient at best, especially when you’re juggling multiple dishes. If your oven takes too long to reach the desired temperature, it may impact your entire cooking schedule.

Common causes

Slow preheating can stem from:

• Worn heating elements that aren’t working at full capacity.
• Thermostat issues that prevent the oven from heating efficiently.

DIY fixes

If your oven is slow to preheat, try these troubleshooting steps:

• Check the heating elements for visible damage and replace them if needed.
• Calibrate or replace the thermostat if you suspect it’s not accurately reading the temperature.

7. Tips for keeping dinner on track

Sometimes, despite all your efforts, your oven might still have hiccups. In these cases, knowing how to adapt can save the day. With a little creativity, you can make sure each dish is ready for the table, even if the oven isn’t fully cooperative. Here are some alternative ways to keep cooking even if your oven is not working.

Multitasking without the oven

Consider other appliances to get things done:

• Grill or smoker: Perfect for cooking the turkey or other meats.
• Stovetop, slow cooker, or Instant Pot: Great for sides and soups.
• Toaster oven or air fryer: Ideal for reheating or cooking small dishes.

Batch cooking and warming techniques

If your oven’s capacity is limited, try these tips:

• Cook dishes in batches and set them aside to reheat as needed.
• Use an insulated cooler or warming drawer to keep dishes warm until serving time.

Read more: How to fix common appliance issues during Thanksgiving

Additional information

Thank you for reading! We hope this guide helps you get ready to enjoy a Thanksgiving filled with good food, good company, and no kitchen surprises!

If you have any other appliance repair needs or projects, don’t hesitate to explore our other troubleshooting guides and videos.

If you need replacement parts or some extra help with ordering them, grab your model number and head over to AppliancePartsPros.com, where you can chat with a pro, read our DIY blog and more.

Be sure to subscribe to us on YouTube and follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram!