The best oven temperature & settings for homemade pizza
Tracy Beard / Tuesday January 30, 2024
Homemade pizza is a beloved food for good reason. The irresistible combination of a crispy, chewy crust, tangy sauce, gooey cheese, and favorite toppings creates a delicious meal or snack.
While great pizza can be found at restaurants and pizzerias anywhere, there’s nothing quite as satisfying as baking your own pizza at home. With the right techniques and equipment, you can make restaurant-quality pizza from the comfort of your kitchen, where you’re in control. Mastering oven settings related to temperature, pizza position, ideal cooking times, and tools can mean the difference between a crispy, well-baked pizza and a soggy, underdone mess.
If you need any replacement oven parts, just enter your model number at AppliancePartsPros.com to find what you’re looking for. We have thousands of troubleshooting guides and repair videos so you can keep your oven ready for pizza baking.
Let’s explore the ideal oven settings for pizza making at home so you can get that perfect crust and melted cheese every time.
Read More: Cooking Efficiently In Your Oven: 10 Tips And Tricks
The best oven settings & adjustments
Getting your oven settings right is also important to achieve pizza that makes your mouth water. Here are some tips.
What is the best oven temperature for pizza?
The best temperature range for pizza baking is 450°F to 550°F. This high heat helps you get a crisp, nicely browned crust and melted, bubbling cheese.
Thick-crusted pizzas with lots of toppings do well closer to 400°F so the interior ingredients have time to heat through before the outside burns.
Use an oven thermometer to confirm your oven’s true temperature if the results don’t match the dial setting.
With a specialty pizza oven, you’ll also want to pay attention to the interior floor temperature. 700°F to 800°F is ideal. This extremely high heat can cook pizzas in just 2 to 3 minutes.
Allow it to preheat
All ovens need to be preheated before baking. For best results, allow your oven to fully preheat for at least:
- 30 minutes for conventional ovens
- 15 minutes for convection ovens
- 45+ minutes for pizza ovens (so the floor temperature can stabilize)
Even though you might be salivating for that first slice, don’t put pizza in too early, or you might get unwanted results.
Use a pizza stone
Using a pizza stone mimics the results of cooking directly on the hearth floor used in professional pizza ovens. Stones absorb moisture, which can give your homemade pizza a crisper crust. The stone’s dense material holds and radiates heat evenly to avoid burnt bottoms or pale tops.
Be sure to preheat your pizza stone for at least 30 minutes before baking so it can reach the maximum temperature. Dust it with flour or cornmeal first to prevent the pizza dough from sticking.
If you don’t have a stone, you can cook your pizza directly on the oven rack to get the best crispness.
Adjust the oven rack height
Rack placement affects how much radiant heat from the oven ceiling reaches your pizza. It also determines how close your pizza is to the lower heating element in the oven.
For standard ovens, place the pizza on a rack positioned in the lower half of your oven, ideally on a preheated pizza stone. This puts the pie closer to the concentrated lower heat source.
If the pizza browning is uneven, try adjusting the rack height up or down as needed.
Read More: A complete guide to oven rack placement for every type of baked good
Bake for the right amount of time
The amount of time your pizza should bake depends on the oven temperature, the thickness of its crust and how many toppings you’re using.
Here are some general home oven baking times as a starting point:
- 10 – 12 minutes for a thin-crust pizza with moderate toppings
- 15 minutes for a thicker crust or extra toppings
- 8 minutes for frozen pizzas
Make sure to frequently check the pizza near the end of the bake time. If you have an interior oven light, use it to judge the pizza’s doneness by checking for a browned crust and bubbling cheese rather than sticking strictly to a timer.
Read More: Don’t Get Burned! 14 Quick and Easy Oven Safety Tips
Use the right tools
Take the time to collect the proper gear for home pizza making so you can improve your chances of success. Here are some must-have tools:
- Stone – helps your pizza get an evenly baked crispy crust
- Peel – allows for an easy transfer of dressed pizzas into the oven
- Cutter – cuts cleanly through crust, cheese, and toppings
- Oven thermometer – to confirm your oven’s true temperature
Look for tools made of quality materials to promote heat flow and last a long time. Wood and metal options tend to outperform plastic versions.
Common pizza baking problems and solutions
Even when armed with ideal oven settings, you may still encounter some hiccups on while baking homemade pizza. Check out these troubleshooting tips.
| Problem | Solution |
|---|---|
| Pizza crust is pale and soggy | Use a pizza stone; increase the rack height to the upper half of the oven; bake at the max oven temperature; cook it longer |
| Pizza cheese isn’t fully melted | Increase the oven temperature by 25°F; use a lower rack height; cook 2-3 extra minutes |
| Pizza crust is burnt but center is undercooked | Lower the oven temperature by 25°F; use the middle rack height; use a pizza stone; rotate the pizza midway through baking |
| Toppings slide right off pizza | Don’t overtop the pizza; drizzle sauce first, add a light cheese layer, then toppings |
How different ovens handle pizza
How your pizza cooks often depends on what type of oven you have in your kitchen and how you make the most of its strengths for pizza. Home ovens generally fall into one of the following categories:
Conventional oven
This is the standard model found in most homes. Conventional ovens rely on two heating elements—a lower element under the oven floor and an upper element under the ceiling. They heat the surrounding air to generate the desired oven temperature.
Benefits: Very common, affordable option.
Limitations: Heat distribution may be uneven, which can lead to hot and cold spots. Adding a pizza stone improves heat flow.
More considerations: The biggest challenge with using a conventional oven to make pizza at home is uneven heating, which can lead to inconsistent cooking. Here are some settings so you can maximize heat absorption into the crust from all directions while allowing some radiant heat from above to melt and brown the toppings.
- Use a pizza stone and place it on the bottom rack
- Let the stone preheat for 30+ minutes
- Use a lower rack height
- Rotate the pizza halfway through the bake time
Convection oven
Convection ovens include a fan to continuously circulate hot air throughout the interior.
Benefits: Consistent temperatures lead to evenly-baked pizza crusts and toppings.
Limitations: Fan may dry out exposed crust edges. Using a pan can help retain moisture.
More considerations: The convection function’s accelerated heating and drying effect call for some tweaks to prevent over-baking.
- Reduce the baking temperature by 25°F from the recipe
- Preheat for 15 minutes
- Use the middle rack position
- Bake directly on the oven rack
- Check the pizza’s doneness a few minutes before the baking time ends
Combination convection-microwave ovens
As the name suggests, these ovens combine convection heating technology with a microwave.
Benefits: Versatility of convection baking and microwave speed.
Limitations: Smaller capacity than a full oven. Crust and cheese may cook faster than inner ingredients, which increases the risk of pizza getting overdone on the outside.
Pizza ovens
Purpose-built for pizza, these specialty ovens may be wood-fired or use other fuel sources to generate high, even heat for fast, perfect pies.
Benefits: Very high temperatures cook pizza crust and toppings quickly. Provides an even bake.
Limitations: Can be significantly more expensive. Many models require outdoor space.
More considerations: Since these ovens utilize much higher temperatures for a quick bake that seals in moisture, you may need to make the following adjustments:
- Allow for 60+ minutes preheat so the floor temperature can stabilize
- Make sure the interior temperature is 700°F – 800°F
- Use a peel and thoroughly dust it with flour or cornmeal so you can slide the pizza in and out fast without spilling ingredients
- Give the pizza 2-5 minutes of bake time
- Rotate the pizza halfway through cooking
FAQs
For home cooks tackling homemade pizza for the first time, you may have some questions surrounding techniques and details. Here’s more insight on some often-asked aspects of getting it right the first time.
Should I preheat my pizza stone?
Absolutely! Pizza stones bake best when they’re fully preheated along with your oven. The dense materials require around 30 minutes to stabilize at your oven’s target temperature. A hot stone gives you the crispy texture you’re looking for.
Where should I place the pizza stone in my oven?
In a conventional oven, place your pizza stone on the lowest rack position so it’s closest to the concentrated lower heating element. This will concentrate heat directly into the stone so your pizza is well-baked.
Can I bake pizza directly on the oven rack?
Yes! If you don’t have a pizza stone, placing your pie directly on an oven rack is the next best option. Putting the pie on a lower rack allows for more airflow and heat conduction than a flat baking sheet.
How do I keep pizza from sticking without using parchment paper?
For the best crispy texture without paper, thoroughly flour or cornmeal your pizza peel before you assemble the pie and slide it onto a preheated stone or rack. The fine coating keeps the pizza dough from sticking until the pizza is set.
Unleash your inner pizza chef
Thanks for reading! Hopefully this guide has erased any intimidation about homemade pizza baking at home.
Now that you understand your oven environment and how it affects end results, you can tweak your settings and tools as needed for all your pizza recipes. After some experimentation, you’ll nail the perfect crust and topping balance. So preheat that oven, prepare your pizza pie and get ready to wow your taste buds with incredible homemade pizza any night of the week!
And if you have any other appliance repair needs or projects, you can find more resources including our DIY blog at AppliancePartsPros.com. There, you can enter your model number to order the exact parts you need. Most orders arrive in two business days.
You can also reach our award-winning customer service team at 1-877-477-7278, chat with a pro on our website and watch thousands of free video tutorials on our YouTube channel.
Hello there! I’m Tracy, and I’m thrilled to be part of the Appliance Parts Pros team. With two years of service and hands-on experience here, I’ve had the privilege of helping numerous customers troubleshoot their home appliances and find DIY repair solutions.