Chest Freezer or Upright Freezer: Here’s How to Choose

Shopping for a freezer probably isn’t the most exciting thing on your to-do list. But when you finally get one, it can seriously change the game. Whether you want to stock up on grocery sales, freeze garden produce, or just get extra space beyond your regular fridge freezer, having a dedicated freezer is incredibly helpful. But then comes the big question: Chest freezer or upright freezer?

Both are great, but they’re different in ways that can really affect how useful they are in your daily life. So how do you choose the one that’s right for your space, habits, and frozen pizza collection? Let’s break it all down.

What Are They?

Chest Freezers

Chest freezers are the big rectangular freezers that open from the top like a chest. They typically offer more raw storage space for the price and are great for stashing large or oddly shaped items. You’ll often find them in basements, garages, or utility rooms.

Upright Freezers

Upright freezers look just like a refrigerators. They stand vertically, open from the front, and usually have shelves or bins for easy organization. These are ideal if you’re short on space or like having everything at eye level.

Size & Space: What Fits Your Home Best?

Chest Freezers

These guys take up more floor space because they’re wide and low. You’ll need to have room to fully open the lid, and ideally, you want to put them somewhere with good airflow and where you’re not constantly bumping into them.

Pros:

• Great for basements or garages
• Can fit large or awkward-shaped items
• More space per dollar

Cons:

• Can be bulky
• Requires bending over and digging

Upright Freezers

These are vertical, so they take up less floor space but more wall height. They’re easier to place in tight spots like kitchens, laundry rooms, or hallways.

Pros:

• Fits in smaller spaces
• Easier access to everything
  Looks more like a standard appliance

Cons:

• Less interior space for the same footprint
• Can be pricier per cubic foot

Organization: Are You a Stack or a Shelf Person?

Chest Freezers

Chest freezers are essentially big open boxes. Some come with one or two hanging baskets at the top, but that’s about it. The downside is that you may end up playing freezer Tetris every time you want to get to the frozen berries at the bottom.

Best For:

• People who don’t mind digging
• Long-term storage (bulk meats, big meal preps)
• Less frequent access

Pro Tip: Use labeled bins to create “zones” inside a chest freezer. It’s a game-changer.

Upright Freezers

Shelves, drawers, door compartments, you name it. Upright freezers make it easy to organize and categorize everything, so you’re not rooting around blindly hoping for chicken nuggets.

Best For:

• Daily or weekly use
• Organizers and list-lovers
• Smaller families or variety eaters

Energy Efficiency: Who Wins the Power Bill Battle?

Chest Freezers

Because they open from the top, cold air tends to stay inside when you open the lid (cold air sinks!). That means chest freezers lose less cold air when in use, making them more energy-efficient in most cases. They also tend to have better insulation.

Upright Freezers

Opening an upright freezer is like opening a fridge, cold air spills out, especially from upper shelves. While modern upright freezers are much more efficient than they used to be, they still tend to use slightly more energy than chest freezers, especially if they’re frost-free models.

Bottom Line: If you’re looking to save on electricity, chest freezers are usually the winner.

Defrosting: Manual vs. Frost-Free

This might not sound like a big deal… until you have to do it.

Chest Freezers

Most are manual defrost, which means you’ll need to unplug it once or twice a year, empty everything out, and let the ice melt. It’s a bit of a hassle, but they usually develop less frost over time and run quieter.

Upright Freezers

Many upright freezers are frost-free, which means they automatically defrost using fans and heating cycles. You’ll never have to chip away at built-up ice, but they’re noisier and can be slightly less efficient.

Choose Manual Defrost If:

• You’re okay with a little annual maintenance
• You want better energy efficiency\
• You’re storing food for long periods

Choose Frost-Free If:

• You want zero maintenance
• You access the freezer often
• You hate the idea of defrosting anything

Price: What’s the Cost Difference?

When it comes to value, chest freezers usually cost less per cubic foot of storage. You can get a big chest freezer at a relatively low price, which is great if you’re on a budget or just need extra space for meats, frozen meals, or garden produce.

Upright freezers tend to cost more for the same internal volume, but they offer better access and convenience. You’re paying for the shelves, drawers, and frost-free features.

Example:

• A 15 cu. ft. chest freezer might cost $500
• A 15 cu. ft. upright freezer could cost $700–$900

But remember, it’s not just about cost. It’s about how you’ll use it.

Access & Convenience: How Often Will You Use It?

This one’s big. If you’re opening your freezer every day to grab things like smoothie fruit, frozen veggies, or leftovers, you’ll love the easy access of an upright freezer.

If you’re storing bulk meat from your annual Costco haul or freezing garden tomatoes for winter, and you only need to access it every so often, a chest freezer makes more sense.

Who Should Choose What?

Here’s a quick cheat sheet based on different lifestyles:

Meal Preppers & Bulk Shoppers

Winner: Chest Freezer
You’ll get more space for those make-ahead meals and big grocery hauls.

Families with Kids

Winner: Upright Freezer
With kids, convenience is everything. Uprights make it easier to grab snacks, frozen meals, and ice cream without digging.

Small Homes or Apartments

Winner: Upright Freezer
Takes up less floor space and is easier to fit into tighter layouts.

Hunters, Gardeners, and Farmers

Winner: Chest Freezer
You need maximum storage and long-term freezing. Chest freezers are your best friend.

Which Freezer Should You Choose?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, and that’s okay. The real question is:
How do YOU use frozen food?

If you’re looking for value, efficiency, and don’t mind digging a bit, go with a chest freezer.
If you’re all about convenience, organization, and quick access, an upright freezer is probably your match.

And if you really can’t decide? Some people actually have both. A chest freezer in the garage for long-term storage, and an upright freezer inside for everyday essentials.

Whichever one you choose, your future self will thank you every time you avoid an overstuffed fridge freezer or get to enjoy summer berries in the middle of winter.

Where To Find More Info

So there you have it, the freezer face-off! If you need any replacement parts for your appliances, you can enter your model number at AppliancePartsPros.com to locate and order them quickly. Most orders arrive in just two business days, and we have tons of great information in our repair help section and YouTube videos to help you troubleshoot.

Stay connected with the latest DIY tips, tutorial videos, and repair guides by following us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. We love hearing about your repair stories and successes. If you need more help or want personalized guidance, feel free to reach out. We’re ready to help you take on your next project with confidence!

The information in this article may not apply to your specific appliance model. We recommend consulting your manufacturer’s documentation or contact us with any questions.

Keep Reading:

How to Fix Water Leaks in Your Upright Freezer 

Easy fixes when your outdoor freezer acts up in the cold

Where you can and can’t install refrigerators and freezers