My ice maker was making ice, but the tray apparently was not emptying completely. The ice that came out was more like crushed ice than cubes. I repeatedly had to empty the bin because the tray already had leftover ice in it, so the water overflowed into the bin making icebergs. I took a chance that the tray was the issue - I had watched it try to empty and I could see it wasn't doing its job - and replaced it with a new icemaker. It took all of 5 minutes to install and worked like a charm to correct my issue. Pro tip: be sure the silicone water deflector thingy is in the correct place! I am happy with the success of this repair and now have beautiful cubes of ice and no more icebergs.