Carolyn S Sabattus , ME May 05, 2019 Appliance: Maytag Refrigerator MBF1958XEW0 Maytag Refrigerator Mbf1958xew0: Ice maker would not work and freezer gasket torn. How to replace Replacement Icemaker. Replaced ice maker with new one from Appliance Parts Pro along with freezer gasket. 1 People found this story helpful Do-It-Yourself Rating: Repair Time Estimate: 30-60 minutes