I figured it was the controller but you can buy the entire icemaker (less shut-off wire) for just a few dollars more so I opted for it instead. Replacement icemaker arrived in one day!
Removed old icemaker in less than 10 minutes. Checked wiring harness on new icemaker (was the same as the old one). Removed shutoff wire from old unit and put it on the new unit. Reinstalled in refrigerator ( 10-15 minutes). Replaced ice bin and plugged the refrigerator.
In 3-5 hours had my first batch of ice. Let the unit make ice overnight and dumped out the first several batches and replaced the bin.
It is working like a champ!