Replaced keypad and keypad mounting plate. I'm glad I ordered the mounting panel as well, it would have been hard to remove the old keypad from the old bracket panel to reuse it.
The low insertion force connector on the control board had to be lifted up slightly to release the old keypad and insert the new keypad contacts before being locked again.
There was a slight difference between the old and new keypad. The new one had slight tint over the clear display section. Not at all noticeable after installation.