I examined the bucket auger assembly and discovered the helix could spin independently and the blades had a lot of play in them, also the cup wasn't broken but looked pretty scarred up and there was a lot of play there, too. My Profile fridge is 20 years old, and I didn't want to spend money and time replacing parts and then have something else in there break, so I just bought the whole bucket and auger assembly. It arrived in two days, and that new auger assembly is in there nice and tight compared to the old one, which flopped all over the place. I transferred the ice from the old bucket into the new one and put that in the freezer. Ice, cubed and crushed, now dispenses on demand. I never would have been able to diagnose the problem without this site and reading other peoples' experiences. This happened after Xmas and my repair guy was out of town and told me to call him on Monday. So,I started researching it on Friday, had the part ordered by Saturday night, and talked to him on Monday and said I had it figured out. Thank you, AppliancePartPros and all of you DIYers who write in!