Auburn F Tampa , FL November 07, 2015 Appliance: Maytag Refrigerator MFI2568AES12 Maytag Refrigerator Mfi2568aes12: Ice maker was not producing ice. How to replace Icemaker Kit. I order the icemaker replacement after reading other reviews that indicated that it was not a difficult repair..and they were right! The instructions that came with the replacement were accurate. Do-It-Yourself Rating: Repair Time Estimate: 30-60 minutes