Ordered bar from ApplianceParts Pros and two end caps. Had to cut the bar to size create a new cutout for the end cap on the cut end, install the end caps and voila, now I can use that shelf again. Seemed a little pricey for a 20 year old fridge but why not fix it if it’s working. It’s the garage fridge.
Tools: hacksaw and diagonal cutters to make the cutout