After shutting the water supply off to the fridge, I noticed the puddling stopped, indicating it was likely the water control valve. I ordered the part from AppliancePartsPros and received it a couple of days later. I watched the helpful video and installed the part without difficulty in about 20 minutes. I turned the water and power back on and checked for leaks. Problem solved, or at least that one. After installing the new valve however, I was not making any ice in the ice maker. Upon further investigation (and the helpful repair forum), I discovered the inlet pipe to the ice maker had frozen solid. Upon removing the freezer contents into a cooler, I turned off the freezer and removed the ice maker. Then using a regular hair dryer on medium heat, completely removed the ice blockage. I also checked to make sure the ice maker cable was still functioning and that its internal fuse had not blown, which could also cause the ice maker to not work. All checked out and I reinstalled the ice maker and the system is now making ice and behaving normally. And, most importantly, no more puddling. Unfortunately, I neglected to turn off the ice maker during the time the water was off for a few days so the ice maker continued to try and make ice without water and I suspect that led to the unit freezing up from residual water (although only a hunch). If you have this problem, I strongly suggest turning the ice maker off. Thanks for the helpful videos to guide me through all this.