Bruce for Model Number WRS588FIHZ00 My ice maker stopped making ice. It stopped dumpling ice. So, I replaced the Ice Maker assembly, but still no ice. I found the service diagnostics and ran several tests. It detects that the bucket is there, so that switch must be okay. I ran the ice harvest test and it rotated the ice tray. I noticed that the ice level arm comes down all the way while it’s rotating the tray upside down (bucket was empty) then goes back up. When the ice tray rotates back upright, the ice level arm comes down again, but only partially and then goes back up. The harvest test ended with a 22 code. Saying the harvesting completed and the bucket was not full. I was able to do the water fill test and it filled the tray correctly. I also ran the ice tray thermistor test. When there was just water in the tray, it said that it was above harvest temperature, but when it froze it said it was below harvesting temp. So, it appears the thermistor is okay. I am stumped. The diagnostics appear to show that it all works okay, but it doesn’t work in an automated mode.
Answer HI Bruce Thanks for your question. Here's how i would proceedYou’ve actually done a very good job isolating this. Based on those diagnostic results, I would not replace another ice maker, water valve, or thermistor yet. The fact that the unit will harvest and fill when commanded manually tells us most of the ice-making hardware is capable of working.What the “22” result tells usOn the harvest test, 22 means the harvest completed successfully and the ice bucket was detected as NOT full. So what you described with the bail/ice-level arm is normal enough for this test—the control ultimately recognized that there was room for more ice.That means the ice maker is not being prevented from cycling because it thinks the bucket is full.Your diagnostic results are importantYou have essentially proven:Function Result What it tells usBucket detection Pass Control sees bucket/not-full conditionForced harvest Pass – 22 Motor, tray movement and position sensing are workingForced water fill Pass Valve, water supply and fill tube can deliver waterTray thermistor warm Above harvest temp Thermistor responds correctlyTray thermistor frozen Below harvest temp Control can recognize that the ice is cold enoughAutomatic harvest Fails This is where the problem remainsWhirlpool confirms that this model uses an in-door ice maker, and this particular design has wiring running through the freezer-door area.My next check: freezer-door wiringBefore condemning the main control, inspect the wiring harness at the bottom freezer-door hinge very carefully.This model has a known trouble spot where the wires flex every time the freezer door opens. Broken or partially broken conductors in that area can cause some functions to work while others don't. There are reports on this exact WRS588FIHZ00 of the ice maker quitting because of a broken wire at the bottom of the freezer door.Pull the toe grille if necessary and inspect where the freezer-door harness enters/exits the bottom hinge. Look for:Completely broken wiresCracked insulationA wire stretched unusually tightGreen/copper corrosionA conductor broken inside apparently intact insulationPrevious wire repairsGive each individual wire a gentle tug test. A conductor can break internally while the insulation still makes it look connected.If you have a multimeter, an even better test is continuity through the suspect door-harness wires while slowly opening and closing the freezer door. Disconnect power before doing continuity testing.If the door wiring checks goodThen I would start strongly suspecting the main electronic control rather than the new ice maker.Here's why.The refrigerator has all the information necessary to make ice:Ice is frozen ? thermistor reports below harvest temperature ? bucket isn't full ? control should initiate harvest.But it doesn't.Yet when you tell the control to perform a harvest through diagnostics, it does it.That's an important distinction. You're proving the output can operate while the automatic decision/control sequence isn't occurring.I would do one additional experiment before buying a board:Let the ice maker fill using the diagnostic fill test.Allow the water to freeze completely.Verify the tray thermistor test reports below harvest temperature.Verify bucket detection still reports not full.Exit diagnostics completely.Leave the refrigerator alone for several hours.Don't initiate another forced harvest.If several hours later the cubes are still sitting frozen in the mold, go back into diagnostics and immediately run the harvest test.If it dumps those same cubes perfectly and again finishes with 22, that's very strong evidence that the automatic harvest command isn't being initiated.At that point, with the new ice maker plus passing thermistor, bucket, harvest and fill tests, I'd put the door wiring/harness first and the main control second on the suspect list—not another ice maker.One other thing: don't overlook actual freezer temperature. Whirlpool specifies a freezer operating range of roughly -5°F to +5°F, so I'd also put a thermometer near the ice-maker area and verify you're staying around 0°F, rather than relying solely on the displayed set temperature. Read More... Answered by AppliancePartsPros.com | Tuesday, September 8, 2026