It was a bad bearing. I tried to get the bearing out, but it was not budging, so I ordered the full outer tub assembly. It came with the bearings and bearing seal, in addition to the new hoses. It all fit together perfectly and the washer is working great again. I also purchases a new tub seal (replace all seals so no leaks) and outer door gasket (older one was rusting). The videos were amazing and made the project much easier.