The ice maker did not produce any ice for an entire day, so obviously something was wrong. The tray didn't even have water in it.
I tried to reset it to no avail and after checking for power with a multi meter, decided to just buy a new OEM unit from Apliance Parts Pros, who had it at my door in 2 days!
The install took about 10-15 minutes with a 6 in 1 screw driver and works great now!