Answer Hello Chris. You will need to test the P terminal of the switches and see which one is sending power to the light in the off position. Replace that switch on the unit. You can test this with a multi-meter TJMA-DMT3. Here is a link on how to use a multi-meter. http://forum.appliancepartspros.com/oven-repair-including-ranges-cooktops/4810-how-check-continuity-ohmmeter.html Read More... Answered by AppliancePartsPros.com | Wednesday, February 28, 2018