Ordered a new one from you guys. Perfect fit. Took all of 3 seconds to fix it.
This is a Maytag I bought about a year ago new. I expected better from them but to be fair the other bins are all OK. This one typically holds 1 gallon of milk and perhaps another item. Kind of a mystery but fixed now.
Be sure you have the right one for your model. They make 2 that look similar but are different sizes. Measure first.