The unit is 20 years old, so I decided to purchase both a Defrost Heater from AppliancePartsPros and Jenn-Air Refrigerator Defrost Control Board from a competitor. (AppliancePartsPros didn't have the part in stock). The entire cost was < $100USD delivered (Excellent!)... Both were easy to change out, the Defrost Heater was simple a 5 min job (really). The Control Board was a bit more complex but found an excellent video online to walk me through it, here's the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Uw16v7-9gk
The defroster is working excellent, the fridge is nice and cold.