I found the model no. of the refrigerator and copied it down. I googled refrigerator repair parts and there was Appliance Parts Pros. I used them in the past year for dryer parts for my Maytag dryer-another story, but the parts arrived the next day just after noon. I decided to try them again and my refrigerator handle arrived around 12:20 the next day. So maybe it wasn't a fluke after all.
I ordered the handle even though the parts diagram only showed one (1) screw at the top and mine has two (2). I contacted customer service and advised them of my problem and he confirmed the diagram only showed one (1) screw. I asked if he had access to the part to confirm, and he advised he didn't, but assured me this was the the exact replacement part so I ordered it. It had the two (2) screw holes that I needed and was an exact fit. I utilized my existing screws and bottom screw cover and I was finished in under 5 minutes. Thanks to Appliance Parts Pros.