At first I thought the issue was with ice auger itself. Turns out that for some reason the Auger Motor Drive Shaft kept sliding down into the motor far enough to turn, but too far. Order this part. When It arrived it appeared to MOE. Took out two screws with bit driver. Removed old auger drive shaft. Placed thin gasket from old shaft onto new shaft. New shaft seemed about 1/8" longer than original with plastic collar FIXED to it. Dropped it in. Replaced screws. Tested. Works like new. Difficult diagnosis - Super-Easy fix.