After reading someone else's story, we were able to confirm our suspicions of a bad switch. We weren't sure we would be able to get a replacement because of how old the range is but AppliancePartsPros.com had the one needed in stock. once the order was placed, it was shipped within 24 hours.
This was an awesome experience! The last part we has to order was from a different website and it took 4 weeks to get the part.
Thanks appliancepartspros.com!