If you carefully pull the plastic agitator directly up and off the center column, you will expose the plastic agitator coupler. Plastic ridges on the inside of the agitator coupler slide onto the metal agitator stem. After years of use the ridges on the plastic coupler wore off so it not longer connected to the metal stem. Remove the 1/2" nut from the top of the coupler, pull off the old coupler and slide the replacement part on. The replacement comes with its own nut/screw which is slightly different than the original. Screw in the screw, align the plastic agitator column and slide it back on. Repair time, about 10 minutes. Cost: about $13 including shipping.