I searched on line and found this site which addressed this issue via a number of other people with the same problem. It was suggested I try their "Washer Agitator Coupler Kit". It almost seemed to good to be true, but I ordered one. It came in a very timely manner, I installed it and that indeed did fix the problem. The only catch was getting my old agitator out of the machine was not as easy as it could have been, but I did get it out with the help of one of the other people's suggestion. Next getting the old coupler off was very difficult. That had no reflection on Appliance Parts Pros, it was just really stuck. Once I did get the old one off it was a little hard to get the new coupler to seat all the way down. I had to pound it down with a hammer and block of wood to get it in place, but it did finally seat like it should and is working just great.